Insights Blog - Thayer Partners. LLC

Benefits Of Direct Indexing: Tax Advantages For High Net Worth Individuals

Written by Thayer Partners | September 15, 2025

Unlock unparalleled tax benefits and personalized investment strategies with direct indexing, a game-changer for high net worth individuals.

Understanding Direct Indexing: A Primer for High Net Worth Investors

Direct indexing is an investment strategy that allows investors to directly own the individual securities within an index, rather than investing through a mutual fund or an exchange-traded fund (ETF). For high net worth individuals, this approach offers a more tailored investment experience by providing greater control over the assets in their portfolio.

By directly owning the underlying securities, investors can make more precise decisions regarding their portfolio, ensuring it aligns with their financial goals and tax considerations. This level of control is particularly advantageous in tax planning for high net worth investors who often have complex financial needs and goals.

How Direct Indexing Offers Superior Tax Efficiency

One of the standout benefits of direct indexing is its potential for superior tax efficiency. Unlike traditional index funds, which distribute capital gains to all investors, direct indexing allows individuals to manage their own tax liabilities. This can result in significant tax savings, particularly for high net worth individuals who are in higher tax brackets.

By carefully selecting and managing the individual securities in their portfolio, investors can minimize capital gains taxes and take advantage of tax-loss harvesting opportunities throughout the year. This proactive approach to tax management can significantly enhance the after-tax returns of a portfolio.

Personalization and Customization: Tailoring Your Portfolio

Direct indexing offers unparalleled opportunities for personalization and customization. High net worth individuals can tailor their portfolios to reflect their unique financial goals, ethical values, and investment preferences. For example, investors can exclude certain industries or companies that do not align with their values, such as tobacco or fossil fuels.

This level of customization ensures that the portfolio not only meets the financial objectives of the investor but also resonates with their personal beliefs and values. Additionally, investors can adjust their portfolios to manage specific risks or take advantage of market opportunities as they arise.

Tax-Loss Harvesting: Turning Losses into Gains

Tax-loss harvesting is a powerful strategy that involves selling securities at a loss to offset capital gains and reduce overall tax liability. Direct indexing makes it easier to implement this strategy on an ongoing basis, allowing investors to systematically realize losses and reinvest the proceeds in similar, but not identical, securities.

For high net worth individuals, the ability to effectively harvest tax losses can lead to substantial tax savings. These savings can then be reinvested, further compounding the growth of the portfolio over time. By integrating tax-loss harvesting into their investment strategy, investors can turn market downturns into opportunities for tax efficiency and portfolio growth.

Comparing Direct Indexing to Traditional Index Funds

While traditional index funds offer simplicity and broad market exposure, they lack the personalization and tax efficiency of direct indexing. Traditional index funds distribute capital gains to all shareholders, which can lead to unexpected tax liabilities, especially for high net worth investors.

In contrast, direct indexing provides greater control over tax management and the ability to customize the portfolio to meet specific investment goals. While direct indexing may require more active management and higher initial setup costs, the long-term benefits in terms of tax savings and personalized investment strategies can outweigh these considerations for high net worth individuals.